2010 Robert Stemmler Estate Pinot Noir Carneros (Wines by Winery / Robert Stemmler Vineyards)

94pts(WE) Cellar Selection This very interesting wine treads a delicate balance between exuberantly ripe persimmons and cherries, and earthier notes of red tomatoes. But those tomatoes are rich and satisfying, like summer heirloom varieties picked fresh off the vine that are sweet as a peaches. Veteran Stemmler, who can usually be depended on to turn out serious Pinot Noir, has succeeded here, giving us a delicious wine for drinking now, but one whose balance should protect it for 6–8 years. Steve Heimoff Wine Enthusiast July 1, 2013